Take the Leap
Quick Takeaways
- A vertical tasting means pouring the same wine from the same winery across different vintages, side by side, so guests can taste how one wine evolves over time.
- You need three bottles minimum. Stags' Leap Winery's Audentia Cabernet Sauvignon collection currently offers three vintages built for exactly this: 2017, 2019, and 2021.
- Pour two ounces per wine, per guest, tasting from youngest to oldest, and cleanse the palate with a plain cracker between pours.
- Skip flowers and candles. Scent competes with the wine's aroma, which is half the tasting experience.
- Pair with a cheese and charcuterie board after guests have tasted each wine at least twice.
- Winemaking and vintage notes for every Stags' Leap wine live on each product page, so guests can follow along in real time.
What Is a Vertical Wine Tasting?
A vertical wine tasting is a side-by-side comparison of the same wine, from the same winery and vineyard, across multiple vintages. Instead of tasting different wines, you are tasting the same wine at different points in time, which means every variable except the year is held constant.
That makes verticals one of the most educational formats in wine. Weather, harvest timing, barrel aging, and even small winemaking adjustments all show up in the glass, and a vertical is the fastest way to actually taste those differences rather than just read about them.
It is also one of the most social formats. Because everyone is tasting the exact same three wines, there is a shared reference point for conversation. A first-time taster and a longtime collector can compare notes on equal footing, and both walk away having learned something.
Your Step-by-Step Guide to Hosting a Vertical Tasting
1. Choose the Wine
Pick three bottles of the same wine from the same producer, in three different vintages. This is what turns a wine night into a vertical: the constant is the wine, and the variable is time.
Stags' Leap Winery's own Audentia Cabernet Sauvignon is built for this. Audentia is a block-selected wine crafted from the estate's own vineyard in the Stags Leap District, and current releases include the following vintages:
| Vintage | Critic Score | Price | Availability |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2017 Audentia Cabernet Sauvignon | 96 Points | Wine Club exclusive | Join the Club to unlock |
| 2019 Audentia Cabernet Sauvignon | 94 Points | $250 | In stock |
| 2021 Audentia Cabernet Sauvignon | 96 Points | $175 | In stock |
The 2019 Audentia is sourced from Block 11, a lower-vigor section of the estate vineyard that produces smaller berries and more concentrated fruit. The 2021 Audentia is a block selection built primarily from Cabernet Sauvignon with a small amount of Cabernet Franc, giving it a more perfumed, floral character than its predecessors. Tasting those two side by side, and adding the Wine Club-exclusive 2017 if you are a member, gives your guests a genuine range to compare.
Prefer a different price point? The Leap Cabernet Sauvignon also spans multiple current vintages and works well as a more approachable vertical.
SHOP THE AUDENTIA VERTICAL COLLECTION
2. Set the Scene
Aromas compete with each other, so skip the flowers and scented candles. A vertical tasting depends on your guests' noses being able to isolate what is actually in the glass.
What does help:
- Soft, low mood lighting
- Background music at a low volume, so conversation carries easily
- One glass per wine, per guest (three glasses per person for a three-wine vertical)
- Neutral, unscented surfaces (avoid scented candles or diffusers on the table)
3. Pour and Taste in Order
- Pour two ounces of each wine into its own glass.
- Arrange the flight from youngest to oldest, left to right.
- Taste as a group, moving through the wines together so everyone is discussing the same vintage at the same time.
- Give each guest a pencil and paper to jot down first impressions. These notes make for great conversation once everyone has tasted all three.
4. Add Food, Strategically
Food is a tool here, not a distraction, if you introduce it at the right moment.
- Between wines: a plain, unflavored cracker cleanses the palate so the next vintage tastes true.
- During tasting: take at least two sips of each wine before moving on. The second sip lets your palate adjust and pick up subtleties the first sip misses.
- After the full flight: bring out a cheese and charcuterie board. Rich, fatty foods soften tannins and can bring out fruit and spice notes that a bare palate might miss.
5. Guide the Conversation
Every Stags' Leap wine page includes winemaking notes, vineyard block information, and vintage conditions. Pull those up for each wine as you taste, so guests can connect what they taste in the glass to what happened in the vineyard that year.
"Made solely from the estate's Block 11, a limited-vigor site that consistently delivers smaller berries and clusters." — tasting note on the 2019 Audentia Cabernet Sauvignon
Encourage guests to compare notes out loud. Which vintage is boldest? Which is most elegant? By the end, pour everyone a full glass of their favorite and let the conversation continue.
Vertical Tasting Cheat Sheet
| Element | What You Need |
|---|---|
| Bottles | 3 vintages, same wine, same producer |
| Glasses | 1 per wine, per guest (3 per guest for a 3-wine vertical) |
| Pour size | 2 oz per wine |
| Tasting order | Youngest to oldest |
| Palate cleanser | Plain, unflavored crackers |
| Minimum sips | 2 per wine, before moving on |
| Food pairing | Cheese and charcuterie, served after the full flight |
| Reference material | Winemaking and vintage notes from each product page |
| Setting | No flowers, no candles, low lighting, soft music |
Why This Works: A Word From Our Winemaker
Vertical tastings are one of the clearest windows into a winemaker's philosophy, because they show how a single site expresses itself year to year. At Stags' Leap Winery, that philosophy is led today by Senior Winemaker and General Manager Ludovic Dervin, a native of France's Champagne region who joined the estate in 2022 and brings an Old World approach to the winery's 85-acre Stags Leap District vineyard. Read more about his approach on our Winemaking page, or catch up on his arrival at the estate.
The estate itself has a story worth sharing at your tasting table. Stags' Leap Winery was founded in 1893, fell dormant during Prohibition, and was re-established in 1971. Its vineyard sits within the Stags Leap District AVA, one of Napa Valley's smallest and most distinctive appellations, known for producing wines with a signature combination of power and soft, velvety tannins. You can walk through that full history on our Colorful History page.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is a vertical wine tasting? A vertical wine tasting is a tasting of the same wine from the same winery across multiple vintages, poured side by side so guests can compare how the wine changes from year to year.
How many bottles do I need to host a vertical tasting? Three bottles is the standard starting point: enough to show a meaningful range without overwhelming your guests' palates in one sitting.
What wine works best for a vertical tasting? Any wine with multiple available vintages from the same producer works, but Cabernet Sauvignon is a popular choice because it ages well and shows clear vintage variation. Stags' Leap Winery's Audentia Cabernet Sauvignon is crafted specifically as a benchmark, single-vineyard Cabernet, which makes it a strong option for a vertical.
How much wine should I pour per taster? Two ounces per wine is standard for a tasting flight. That is enough to evaluate color, aroma, and flavor without over-serving guests across a three or four-wine flight.
Should I serve food during a vertical tasting? Yes, but with intention. Use plain crackers as a palate cleanser between wines, and save richer pairings like cheese and charcuterie for after guests have tasted the full flight at least twice.
Where can I find winemaking and vintage notes for Stags' Leap wines? Every wine on stagsleap.com includes a dedicated product page with winemaking notes, vineyard and block information, and vintage conditions, all of which are useful reference material during a tasting.
How can I try a vertical tasting without buying full bottles myself? Stags' Leap Winery Wine Club members get access to member-exclusive vintages, like the 2017 Audentia, along with priority access to new releases. Join the Wine Club to explore those options, or book a guided tasting through our Virtual Wine Tasting experience.
